How a THC Brain-Imaging Classifier Defined Impairment

THC Vaporized and THC edibles

A brain-imaging classifier can only be evaluated in relation to the outcome used to label its training data. In a THC study using functional near-infrared spectroscopy, “impairment” was defined through agreement between clinical ratings and an algorithm incorporating heart rate and self-reported intoxication. It was not established by an on-road driving test.

The reference definition came first

Gilman and colleagues studied regular cannabis users in a double-blind crossover experiment involving individualized oral dronabinol and placebo. A total of 169 participants received study drug and had at least one post-dose scan.

The investigators measured prefrontal oxygenated-hemoglobin responses during a working-memory task. To construct the classification reference, they required concordance between two clinical raters and a separate physiological and subjective algorithm. Participants with discordant determinations did not supply the same clearly labeled training examples.

Classification and drug detection are different objectives

The investigators trained machine-learning models using temporal and connectivity features of the imaging signal. Their analyses distinguished participants operationally labeled impaired from comparison observations and separately examined scans labeled “not clearly impaired” after THC.

Importantly, receiving THC was not automatically treated as equivalent to impairment. Participants given similar doses could receive different reference labels. That is a useful conceptual distinction, but it does not turn the chosen label into an independently proven measure of every safety-sensitive activity.

What external validation still has to answer

A classifier’s accuracy depends on the population, the reference definition and the conditions of testing. Predictive value also depends on how common the target condition is in the population where the device is used. Performance in this controlled experiment should not be assumed for an unselected roadside population, other drugs or relevant medical conditions.

The journal issued a correction to Figure 2; the corrected original should accompany interpretation of the study.

This research asks an individual-classification question. Our article on prefrontal connectivity after THC concerns a related but distinct imaging approach. Neither kind of signal should be described as a validated legal conclusion about a person’s driving without evidence connecting the test to that intended use.

Primary research

Identification of ∆9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) impairment using functional brain imaging. DOI: 10.1038/s41386-021-01259-0.

Spread the love


The National Black Lawyers

top 40 lawyers

civil trial law

Lawyers of Distinction

Loading...

Recent Blog Articles

What Did Mental Health Professionals Report After a Breathwork Workshop?

Ulrike Lueken and colleagues asked 48 mental health professionals to take part in a high-ventilation breathwork workshop and rate their experience. The participants reported altered states and also gave their judgments about possible therapeutic uses and risks. Those ratings describe the views of the workshop group. They do not measure…

Spread the love

Read Article: What Did Mental Health Professionals Report After a Breathwork Workshop?

What Changed on an Emotional Face Recognition Task After Psilocybin With Support?

In an open-label study, J. B. Stroud and colleagues found that people with treatment-resistant depression recognized facial emotions faster one month after receiving psilocybin with psychological support. Seventeen patients completed the task at baseline and follow-up. Sixteen untreated controls completed it on the same schedule. The researchers reported a group-by-time…

Spread the love

Read Article: What Changed on an Emotional Face Recognition Task After Psilocybin With Support?

What Did a Young-Adult CBD Survey Reveal About How Users Chose a Dose?

A survey of young adults asked how CBD users chose a dose. Their answers show why a product history needs more detail than a report of CBD use.

Spread the love

Read Article: What Did a Young-Adult CBD Survey Reveal About How Users Chose a Dose?

Speak with an expert today!

Contact the offices of Okorie Okorocha for professional and reliable advice which you can trust.

Call (424) 363-3347 Contact Us