Can a Meta-Analysis Identify the Best Psychological Support Protocol for Psilocybin Trials?
Psilocybin-assisted therapy trials can combine the drug with different forms of psychological support. Chen and colleagues asked whether the support protocol was associated with differences in depressive symptoms across studies.
What the review compared
The analysis included 10 eligible studies with 515 adults. The authors classified the protocols by whether providers followed a manual and whether the intervention involved directive psychotherapy, nondirective support, or supportive psychotherapy. Some categories contained a single study. The authors used Bayesian meta-analysis and meta-regression to compare outcomes across the categories.
Why a nonsignificant result leaves the question open
The comparisons did not identify significant differences relative to manualized nondirective support. That finding does not establish equivalence. With few studies in some categories, a protocol comparison can also reflect differences in study populations or design. The analysis classified support at the study level, without independently assigning individuals to support protocols within a common trial design.
What a direct comparison could add
A trial comparing prespecified support protocols under otherwise similar conditions could better isolate the contribution of the support model. It could also measure adherence to the protocol and define what size of difference would matter clinically.
Source
Chen MH, Cheng SL, Kao YC, et al. The association between diverse psychological protocols and the efficacy of psilocybin-assisted therapy for clinical depressive symptoms: a Bayesian meta-analysis. Frontiers in Psychiatry. 2024;15:1439347. DOI 10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1439347.



