What Can Two Kidney Biopsy Patterns Establish After Cocaine Exposure?
A kidney biopsy can document more than one injury pattern in the same patient. A case reported by Carrara and colleagues shows why detailed pathology can strengthen the diagnosis of injury while leaving its cause uncertain.
What the biopsy showed
The patient had acute renal failure and a history of chronic cocaine use. The biopsy showed necrotizing and crescentic glomerulonephritis, a pattern of injury in the kidney’s filtering units, together with membranous nephropathy, a pattern associated with deposits along the glomerular capillary wall. The authors described the crescentic process as pauci-immune. Electron microscopy separately identified deposits consistent with the membranous component. Those findings explain why the authors reported two concurrent patterns.
Where the causal inference begins
The report treated levamisole exposure as presumed. A cocaine history does not establish which adulterants were present in the product, and a biopsy assesses tissue injury rather than identifying the material consumed. The authors proposed levamisole as a possible explanation for the combination. The case cannot determine whether levamisole caused either component, whether the two had a shared cause, or how often the combination occurs.
How to describe the evidence
The pathology, the exposure history and the proposed mechanism belong in separate parts of a case assessment. The biopsy supports the presence of both kidney injury patterns. The history supports cocaine exposure as reported. The proposed connection to levamisole remains a hypothesis based on this case.
Study
Carrara C, Emili S, Lin M, Alpers CE. Necrotizing and crescentic glomerulonephritis with membranous nephropathy in a patient exposed to levamisole-adulterated cocaine. Clinical Kidney Journal. 2016;9(2):234–238. DOI 10.1093/ckj/sfv141.



