How Strong Was the Evidence for a Theoretical Postmortem Redistribution Factor?

The proposed theoretical postmortem redistribution factor was tested against a small set of paired case examples. The reported statistical relationship supports further study, but it is not a universal reconstruction of blood concentration before death.

What was compared?

McIntyre compared an observed factor, F, calculated from antemortem and postmortem peripheral blood results, with a theoretical factor, Ft, based on a drug’s liver-to-peripheral blood ratio. The paper presents 13 examples involving nine drugs from nine cases. The reported linear comparison had R² of 0.7006 and P=0.001.

What does that relationship mean?

It indicates an association within these examples between the observed and theoretical quantities. It does not say the model explains every individual measurement, works for every drug, or removes uncertainty from collection timing. R² is a property of this sample and model, not a guarantee of accuracy for a future case.

What should a case reviewer ask?

Check whether a genuine antemortem measurement exists, when it was collected, the postmortem interval, specimen site and validated analytical method. The paper provides a model for cautious interpretation; it does not make a postmortem concentration interchangeable with an antemortem one.

Scientific source: McIntyre IM. Analytical data supporting the “theoretical” postmortem redistribution factor (Ft): a new model to evaluate postmortem redistribution. Forensic Sciences Research. 2016;1(1):33–37. doi:10.1080/20961790.2016.1253255.

Spread the love


The National Black Lawyers

top 40 lawyers

civil trial law

Lawyers of Distinction

Loading...

Recent Blog Articles

Why Were Sixteen On-Road Cannabis Test Drives Stopped?

Safety-related test termination is part of the trial record and should not disappear behind a lane-weaving average. In Arkell and colleagues’ on-road crossover trial, 16 of 188 test drives, or 8.5%, were ended because of safety concerns. How was the study structured? Twenty-six healthy occasional cannabis users were randomized across…

Spread the love

Read Article: Why Were Sixteen On-Road Cannabis Test Drives Stopped?

When Does a Brain GHB Cutoff Become Unreliable After Death?

A proposed brain GHB cutoff is not reliable without considering decomposition. Thomsen and colleagues suggested 10 mg/kg as a tentative distinction between postmortem formation and prior intake, while identifying extensively decomposed bodies as an important exception. How was the proposal developed? The study analyzed frontal-lobe gray matter and femoral blood…

Spread the love

Read Article: When Does a Brain GHB Cutoff Become Unreliable After Death?

Did Twelve Hours Without Cannabis Make a Positive Urine Screen an Acute-Intoxication Test?

A positive urine cannabinoid screen in this study was a use-history criterion, not proof of acute intoxication during the driving test. The researchers separately required a 12-hour abstinence period and rescheduled participants reporting more recent use or appearing intoxicated. How were participants selected? Dahlgren and colleagues recruited 28 chronic, heavy…

Spread the love

Read Article: Did Twelve Hours Without Cannabis Make a Positive Urine Screen an Acute-Intoxication Test?

Speak with an expert today!

Contact the offices of Okorie Okorocha for professional and reliable advice which you can trust.

Call (424) 363-3347 Contact Us