Does a Link Between Psilocybin Use and Nature Relatedness Establish Cause?
A statistical association between past psilocybin use and feeling connected to nature does not establish that taking psilocybin caused that connection.
What was compared
Forstmann and colleagues reanalyzed five datasets comprising 3,817 participants. Among psychedelic-experienced participants, psilocybin experience was the most reliable substance-use predictor of self-reported nature relatedness. The analyses considered experience with several compounds rather than treating all psychedelic use as one exposure.
What remains uncertain
Comparing experienced users reduces some differences between users and nonusers. It does not randomly assign a substance or remove all differences in personality, expectations, motives and settings. The authors identified controlled studies as an important next step.
The outcome was a reported relationship with nature. It should not be treated as a direct measurement of changed environmental behavior. Compound-specific prediction and a demonstrated causal effect remain separate claims.
Source
Forstmann M et al. Among psychedelic-experienced users, only past use of psilocybin reliably predicts nature relatedness. Journal of Psychopharmacology. 2023. DOI 10.1177/02698811221146356.



