Why 98.7% Fingerprint THC Agreement Needs Its Underlying Counts

THC Vaporized and THC edibles

A fingerprint THC screen achieved 98.7% agreement with laboratory fingerprint testing in 75 postmortem cases. The underlying counts were 73 true negatives, one true positive and one false positive. Those numbers convey much more about the evidence than the headline percentage alone.

What “accuracy” referred to

Hudson and colleagues evaluated a fluorescence-based lateral-flow device using sweat remaining in fingerprints collected from deceased individuals. A second fingerprint collected in parallel was analyzed by liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry.

For THC, the screen used a cutoff of 190 picograms per fingerprint. Its 98.7% accuracy was agreement with the laboratory classification of the comparison fingerprint. It did not measure agreement with observed intoxication, driving ability or the person’s condition at a known earlier time.

One confirmed positive cannot support a broad sensitivity claim

The study’s table reported 100% THC sensitivity because the single laboratory-positive case was detected. It also reported a 50% positive predictive value: only one of the two positive screens was confirmed in the comparison fingerprint.

These measures are mathematically consistent. High overall accuracy was largely driven by correctly classifying negative samples. With only one confirmed THC-positive specimen, the sensitivity estimate is especially uncertain. It should not be advertised as proof that the device detects every cannabis user.

Matrix and contamination remain relevant

The authors identified accidental contact as a potential issue when detecting parent THC on fingers. A handwashing strategy possible in living volunteers was unavailable for these postmortem cases. Confirming THC chemically does not automatically resolve how it reached the fingerprint.

Blood and urine comparisons also involve different matrices and available sample counts. Their agreement figures should not be pooled with the 75 fingerprint comparisons as though they measure one identical outcome. Several authors were affiliated with the device manufacturer, a relevant context for evaluating product-development research.

The study supports further examination of a screening method, with confirmation of positives. As with other cannabis evidence, chemical presence, route of exposure and impairment are separate questions.

Primary research

Drug screening using the sweat of a fingerprint: lateral flow detection of Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol, cocaine, opiates and amphetamine. DOI: 10.1093/jat/bky068.

Spread the love


The National Black Lawyers

top 40 lawyers

civil trial law

Lawyers of Distinction

Loading...

Recent Blog Articles

What Was Randomized in a Survey Comparing Intense Drug Experiences?

The experience being reported was selected through survey-routing procedures. The substance exposure itself was not randomly assigned. That distinction determines what a retrospective comparison can establish. Routing participants to past experiences Chwyl and colleagues’ supplied preprint analyzed 397 adults reporting on intense psilocybin, MDMA or cannabis experiences within the previous…

Spread the love

Read Article: What Was Randomized in a Survey Comparing Intense Drug Experiences?

How Do Naturalistic Human Observations Differ From Mouse Tests of Visual Prediction?

A supplied preprint combined observational human comparisons with controlled mouse experiments. Those evidence streams can inform one another without carrying the same causal weight. Recent use was observed in people West and colleagues compared visual responses in recent psychedelic users and controls. Dose and potency could not be directly established….

Spread the love

Read Article: How Do Naturalistic Human Observations Differ From Mouse Tests of Visual Prediction?

Does a Link Between Psilocybin Use and Nature Relatedness Establish Cause?

A statistical association between past psilocybin use and feeling connected to nature does not establish that taking psilocybin caused that connection. What was compared Forstmann and colleagues reanalyzed five datasets comprising 3,817 participants. Among psychedelic-experienced participants, psilocybin experience was the most reliable substance-use predictor of self-reported nature relatedness. The analyses…

Spread the love

Read Article: Does a Link Between Psilocybin Use and Nature Relatedness Establish Cause?

Speak with an expert today!

Contact the offices of Okorie Okorocha for professional and reliable advice which you can trust.

Call (424) 363-3347 Contact Us