Did a 165-Patient Model Predict Future Suicide Attempts?
A study of 165 patients using crystal methamphetamine at two Iraqi treatment settings modeled suicidal ideation. The reported classification accuracy was 79.4%. That number concerns the study’s measured outcome, not observed prediction of future suicide attempts.
What was assessed
The researchers used a cross-sectional convenience sample collected in 2021. They analyzed associations between patient characteristics and suicidal ideation using logistic regression. Current ideation and later attempts are different endpoints; the study did not prospectively follow patients to test an attempt-prediction rule.
Why model fit is not enough
A goodness-of-fit test describes one aspect of how a model relates to its data. It does not independently demonstrate performance in a new clinic or population. Small samples, selection into care and limited representation of women also affect how far results can travel.
The study supplies exploratory associations within its sample. Its accuracy estimate should not be presented as an individual probability of a future attempt or used to claim that someone is safe.
Source: Al-Imam A et al. Brain Sciences. 2023;13:1279. doi:10.3390/brainsci13091279.



